Skip to content

HDRN Canada’s IDEA & Public Engagement Reflection Tool helps teams consider inclusion, diversity, equity and accessibility (IDEA), community perspectives, and reciprocity in their work. Developed out of HDRN Canada’s IDEA Strategy, it provides a flexible framework for reflection and discussion during planning and decision-making, helping teams identify critical perspectives and considerations. Reflection questions cover five areas: context, knowledge and perspectives; readiness; supports and accessibility; power and reciprocity; and reflection and adaptation. It can be used when developing new initiatives, reviewing existing work or revisiting decisions. It is accompanied by a Companion Guide to support further learning and deeper reflection.

Text reads: HDRN Canada IDEA & Public Engagement Reflection Tool

IDEA & Public Engagement Companion Guide

Why this matters

Impacts are not experienced equally across all populations. Considering who benefits and who may face barriers can help identify unintended consequences early. The goal is not only to identify risks or inequities, but also to explore how projects, policies and initiatives can contribute to more equitable outcomes

Things to consider

  • How might this work impact people and/or communities?
  • Who may be unintentionally excluded?
  • Who benefits? Who may be privileged by this work? Who might be harmed?
  • Are impacts likely to differ across groups?

Helpful resources

Why this matters

Strong decisions are informed by multiple forms of knowledge. Considering what evidence is included, and what may be missing, can help identify gaps and assumptions.

Things to consider

  • What evidence or information is currently informing this work?
  • Are lived and living experiences represented?
  • Have community or public perspectives already been gathered elsewhere?
  • What forms of knowledge may be missing?
  • Are some sources of knowledge being prioritized over others?

Helpful resources

Examples of evidence to draw on

  • Peer-reviewed and grey literature
  • Administrative and other existing data
  • Lived/living experience
  • Previous public or community engagement
  • Public Advisory Council/partner recommendations
  • Community needs assessments
  • Indigenous/community knowledge where appropriate and shared through appropriate protocols
  • Organizational experience and operational knowledge
  • Subject-matter expertise
  • Existing IDEA/data equity assessments

Why this matters

Missing perspectives can create blind spots and increase the risk that decisions do not reflect the realities of those affected.

Things to consider

  • Who are trusted connectors, organizations or networks that may already have relationships with the people or communities we hope to reach? 
  • Are we asking people to engage with us directly when an existing relationship or community network could provide a more appropriate pathway?
  • Who has direct experience with the issue?
  • Which communities may be affected but are not currently represented?
  • Are equity-deserving groups included?
  • Are there geographic, cultural, linguistic or accessibility considerations?
  • What expertise may be missing from current discussions?

Helpful resources

Things to consider

  • Do we have sufficient time, resources and/or funding?
  • Do we have the necessary relationships?
  • Is there trust or a pathway for building it?
  • Do we have the capacity to participate and support participation?
  • Can we actually act on what we learn?
  • Is the issue relevant to the people we are hoping to involve?
  • Are there existing networks, knowledge or engagement that we should build on?
  • Is the proposed approach appropriate for the context?

Helpful resources

Why this matters

There are multiple ways to incorporate IDEA principles and community or public perspectives into your work. Public engagement may be one option, but it is not the only one. The appropriate approach depends on the context, purpose, relationships, capacity and ability to act on what is learned.

When making the decision about which option(s) to choose, consider the following:

  • Has relevant engagement already taken place?
  • Are there data equity considerations that should be addressed?
  • Would consultation with internal or external experts be helpful?
  • Is additional input needed to inform decisions?
  • Could more than one action be appropriate?
  • Is training needed?

Option 1: Engage with People and/or Communities

Consider this option when:

  • Missing perspectives are needed to move forward 
  • Decisions may directly affect communities
  • Input from the public can meaningfully influence approach and outcomes
  • There is capacity and resources available to support engagement (e.g., funding, compensation, experience, etc). 

Conceptual Framework / Reflections if pursuing this option 

  • Before Engagement: Do the foundations exist? 
    • Think about: relevance, trust, previous experiences, existing knowledge, missing perspectives. 
  • Before and During Relationship-Building: Are we creating the right conditions? 
    • Think about: time, relationships, networks, accessibility, capacity, power. 
  • Before Choosing an Engagement Approach: Are we choosing an approach that fits the context? 
    • Think about: capacity, motivation, purpose, decision-making authority, flexibility, methods, time. 

Examples:

  • Public Advisors / Public Advisory Councils / Public Partners 
  • Community organizations
  • Equity-deserving groups

Helpful resources 

  • CIHR – SPOR Patient Engagement Framework
    •  Consider this resource as a foundational resource for understanding the role of engagement in priority setting, decision-making, research and knowledge translation.

Option 2: Consult Existing Knowledge and Evidence 

When:

  • Engagement may have already occurred elsewhere
  • Communities have repeatedly identified priorities
  • Existing evidence can appropriately support/inform action

Examples:

  • Literature reviews
  • Prior engagement reports
  • Public advisory recommendations
  • Environmental scans
  • Grey literature
  • Existing community needs assessments

Option 3: Apply Data Equity Practices 

When:

  • The issue relates primarily to data, methods, analysis, representation or interpretation

Examples:

  • Data equity review
  • Bias assessment
  • Examination of missing populations
  • Equity-focused analytic approaches
  • Review of disaggregated data

Helpful resources 

Option 4: Seek Support and/or Consultation 

When:

  • Team is uncertain
  • Capacity is limited
  • Trade-offs exist

Within HDRN Canada:

  • IDEA Team 
  • Public Engagement Team 
  • Public Advisory Council (PAC) 

Outside HDRN Canada

  • SPOR SUPPORT Units
  • Community organizations
  • Patient/public partners
  • Indigenous organizations/knowledge holders where appropriate

Helpful resources 

Option 5: Combination of the Above 

This option involves a combination of two or more of the above approaches to inform or support a decision. Different approaches may be appropriate at different stages of the work, or may be used together to bring in different types of knowledge and perspectives.

For example, a team might combine existing evidence with input from people with lived and living experience, consultation with community and internal discussion or reflection. The combination of approaches should be guided by the purpose of the work, who may be affected, what knowledge is needed, and the time and resources available. 

Using multiple approaches does not necessarily mean that more engagement is better. Consider what each approach contributes, where there may be gaps and how the information or perspectives gathered will be considered in decision-making.

Why this matters

Meaningful engagement, consultation or IDEA-related activities require appropriate capacity, planning and commitment. Identifying inequities, barriers or missing perspectives is only one part of the reflection process. Teams should also consider their readiness to respond. Readiness includes not only resources such as time and funding, but also decision-making, flexibility, organizational support, relationships with communities and the ability to adapt plans based on what is learned.

Time is more than a project timeline. Teams should consider not only whether there is sufficient time to conduct engagement, but whether there is sufficient time to build relationships, understand context, establish trust and respond meaningfully to what is learned.

Things to consider

  • Can we actually make changes based on what we learn?
  • Can findings or input realistically influence decisions?
  • Do team members have the necessary skills or training?
  • What supports may be needed before proceeding?
  • Do we have trusted relationships or pathways to conduct this work?
  • Which aspects of the initiative are open to change?
  • Are there existing processes, mandates or constraints that limit options?

Helpful resources

Why this matters

Identifying supports early can help strengthen planning, avoid challenges later, and improve the quality of decision-making.

Things to consider

  • Who should be involved in early discussions?
  • What expertise or perspectives are needed?
  • Are there internal supports that could help?
  • Are external partnerships or relationships needed?
  • What information is still required before moving forward?

Helpful resources 

Operational support: For operational work within HDRN Canada, consider connecting with existing teams and advisory bodies that can bring different expertise and perspectives to the work. Depending on the question or decision, relevant supports may include:

  • Public Engagement Team and Public Advisory Council: For questions about meaningful public engagement, community perspectives, relationship-building and how people with lived experience can help shape the work. HDRN Canada’s Public Engagement Team works with the Public Advisory Council to support meaningful public participation across the network.
  • IDEA Team: For support in considering inclusion, diversity, equity and accessibility throughout planning and decision-making, including identifying potential barriers or perspectives that may be missing. See HDRN Canada’s IDEA Strategy
  • First Nations, Inuit and Métis Learning / Indigenous Data Governance supports: Where work involves Indigenous Peoples, communities or data, consider seeking appropriate guidance early and engaging with relevant Indigenous partners and governance structures. 

The goal is not necessarily to involve all of these groups, but to identify who has the knowledge, relationships, lived experience or decision-making role needed for this particular piece of work, and involve them early enough to meaningfully influence the approach.

For general questions about HDRN Canada’s work or who may be best positioned to help, contact info@hdrn.ca.

Research-related support: For work involving research, additional external supports may be available, depending on jurisdiction. The SPOR SUPPORT Units provide access to expertise and support for public and patient-oriented research, including patient/public engagement, research methods, data, training, knowledge mobilization and connections with decision-makers and community partners. 

If your work involves research, consider contacting the SPOR SUPPORT Unit in your province or territory to explore what support may be available. CIHR maintains a current list of SUPPORT Units across Canada, with links to the individual units.

The SPOR SUPPORT Units serve British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Ontario, Quebec, the Maritimes, Newfoundland and Labrador, Yukon, the Northwest Territories and Nunavut.

Note: You do not need to have every aspect of a project figured out before seeking support. Early conversations can help identify expertise, partnerships, methodological considerations or engagement needs that may affect how the work is planned.

Why this matters

Barriers can prevent people from participating, benefiting or being meaningfully considered in decision-making processes.

Things to consider

  • Who may face barriers to participation or involvement?
  • Is the environment welcoming and supportive for individuals sharing their perspectives?
  • Are there accessibility considerations?
  • Are there language, cultural, geographic, financial or technological barriers?
  • What accommodations or supports could help reduce barriers?
  • Are there organizational barriers that may need to be addressed?

Helpful resources

Why this matters

Understanding decision-making processes can help ensure transparency, clarify expectations and identify opportunities to share influence.

Things to consider

  • Who has decision-making authority?
  • Who can influence decisions?
  • How will input be considered?
  • Are roles and expectations clear?
  • Are there opportunities to share decision-making or influence?

Helpful resources

Try mapping the decision-making process: Who identifies the issue? Who sets priorities? Who develops options? Who makes the final decision? Who can change the decision? Who will be affected by it?

Why this matters

Reciprocity helps build trust and supports meaningful, mutually beneficial relationships.

Things to consider

  • What contributions are different partners making?
  • What might make participation meaningful or worthwhile for the people and communities involved?
  • What benefits might partners expect or deserve?
  • How will contributions be recognized?
  • What might build or undermine trust in this relationship? 
  • Are benefits distributed fairly?
  • Are we asking people to participate because it is meaningful to them, or primarily because it is useful to us? 
  • How will relationships be maintained over time?
  • Why might people trust this process or organization? 
  • Have previous experiences with researchers, health systems, governments or institutions shaped expectations of this work?

Helpful resources

Why this matters

Impacts, relationships and priorities may change over time. Ongoing reflection can help identify opportunities for improvement and adaptation. Consider who you are engaging with throughout this work and how you might monitor and adapt approaches, e.g., with representatives from different sectors, persons with lived and living experiences, and partners in community and/or government.

Things to consider

  • How will outcomes and impacts be monitored?
  • How will learning be captured and shared?
  • When will decisions be revisited?
  • How will feedback be incorporated?
  • Should engagement or consultation approaches be reconsidered as the work evolves?

Helpful resources